Argumentative Penguin
2 min readDec 4, 2023

--

I have also read Indi.ca's essays on the subject - and I find them to be problematic and poorly thought through. The issue here is essentially that most people are only choosing to read one side of the argument - you have highlighted that exact position by not engaging with any of the stuff I pointed out.

I am not Israeli, nor Jewish, nor do I particularly care for the right wing position that some of the Israeli's have taken here. I'm a left-leaning liberal. However, being a left-leaning liberal comes with certain responsibilities. It comes with a responsibility to be both curious and informed.

You have accused me of not making any points - I did exactly that in the last thread. I have pointed out that there are inherent problems in the confusion between the Gaza civilian population and the radical extremist caliphate that Hamas currently is, I have pointed you towards the UN position on the Hamas charter.... and your current position is 'some Sri Lankan guy spouting off in a largely anti-colonial echo chamber s better informed than you are' - if you aren't prepared to read anything but things you already think then I don't know how to engage with you. You've got an ideology in place of cognitive function.

So, for the record.... I do not support mass slaughter, I have largely eschewed the news coming out of either side in favour of reading I did a few years ago. So I'm not going to support Israel but nor am I going to support the position of Hamas. You, and indeed Indi.ca who says he outright supports Hamas (his words not mine) are playing with theoretical fire. I hope you don't get burned, I can't promise you won't. Indi.ca isn't brave, he's a demagogue, he says what is expedient and simple under the guise of 'speaking truth' and he relies on those who already think along the same lines not to question anything he says.

Repeat ad nauseam

Fade to black.

--

--

Argumentative Penguin
Argumentative Penguin

Written by Argumentative Penguin

Playwright. Screenwriter. Penguin. Fan of rationalism and polite discourse. Find me causing chaos in the comments. Contact: argumentativepenguin@outlook.com

Responses (2)