I see your argument and I raise you jdate…. A specialist dating app for Jewish people. Now…. I don’t care whether people want to make inclusive apps for everyone or exclusive apps for people with particular views/traits etc. What we can’t have is arguing for one thing when it benefits us and the opposite when it benefits others. There’s a reason why jdate exists and it’s because Jewish people want to meet others who share their worldview and outlook.
The fact you disagree with the outlook of this group is neither here nor there. I’m sure they don’t broadly approve of a Jewish only dating app - but we can’t have it both ways.