Well..... this was very interesting to read. I enjoy this sort of back and forth between intelligent people and you're both making a great case for your own interpretation of evil, and doing so in a respectful and interesting way that other people can benefit from.

You should consider agreeing a final deadline, writing opposing articles with a single title (evil is innate) and (evil is learned) and summarise the salient points of your argument and then we'll look at promoting these things via the Panopticon as good healthy debate between people capable of disagreeing whilst still toeing the line of mutual respect. I might write a third 'refereeing' article :o)